From laid-back weekends to last-minute plans, these shirts are built to show up. Our collection includes the everyday essentials guys actually wear—like our top-rated basic tee (seriously, people love it), best-selling button ups in prints that bring a little personality, and polos that cover both standard and performance needs.
Henleys? Yep, they’re here too. Perfect for that not-trying-too-hard casual vibe. Everything is made with quality in mind, because we don’t do throwaway clothes. Just well-made staples that feel good, fit right, and hold up to real life.
Shirts & Polos FAQs
What counts as a shirt in the Shirts & Polos collection?
Everything with a collar, a placket, or buttons — plus the long-sleeve tee. Polos in classic, performance, and sweater builds. Henleys in short and long sleeve, waffle knit included. Button-ups in Essential and Relaxed cuts, short and long sleeve. Flannels. Thirty-six pieces in all, with multipacks across most of them.
Polo, henley, or button-up — how do I choose?
Think about how dressed up you want to look and how much you want to think about it. The polo is the easy middle: collared, put-together, at home in an office or on a course. The henley is the relaxed one — no collar, a short row of buttons, casual but intentional. The button-up is the most formal of the three and the most versatile as a layer, since it works closed or open over a tee. In doubt? The polo covers the most ground.
Do the shirt styles fit consistently with each other?
They do. ITAM builds to one athletic cut across the line — trim through the shoulders and chest with room through the midsection — so your size in a polo is your size in a henley and a button-up. The Relaxed Button Up is the intentional exception, cut roomier by design, and the Vista Sweater Polo sits a touch closer to the body.
Which shirt works for a dinner out or a wedding?
A long-sleeve button-up is the safest call for a wedding, especially in a solid. For dinner, the Vista Sweater Polo does a lot of work — it looks deliberate without needing a jacket over it. And a long-sleeve henley in a dark neutral is the move when the room is more relaxed than that. All three sit in this collection.
Can I layer these shirts over a tee?
One of the best things about them. The short-sleeve button-ups, especially the Relaxed cut, are made to wear open over a plain or graphic tee. Flannels do the same job with more warmth. Long-sleeve button-ups layer cleanly under a jacket, or over a tee with the sleeves rolled. Sizing stays the same either way — no need to go up just to layer.
What are INTO THE AM henleys made of?
The standard Long Sleeve Henley is a premium 60% combed cotton / 40% polyester blend, the same fabric platform as the Basic Tee. The Long Sleeve Waffle Knit Henley is 78% cotton, 18% polyester, 4% spandex, with a textured waffle knit and a touch of stretch.
What is INTO THE AM's return policy?
INTO THE AM offers a 30-day hassle-free return and exchange policy. Items must be unworn and in original condition. Visit intotheam.gorgias.help to start a return.
How long does shipping take?
Place your order before 12 PM PST (Mon-Fri) and we'll aim to ship the same day. Otherwise orders ship within 0-3 business days. We ship via USPS, UPS, DHL, and FedEx.